Torture and the Ticking Time Bomb

I have just posted a version of my SPEP paper from last fall to SSRN, “One View of the Dungeon: The Ticking Time Bomb between Governmentality and Sovereignty” The paper is a critique of one of the standard justifications for torture: “what if there were a ticking time bomb about to blow up Manhattan, and you have the terrorist. Would you torture him to save the lives of millions?” Versions of this argument show up in most efforts to justify torture, and its soundness has been thoroughly criticized by writers such as Kim Scheppele and David Luban. My paper takes a different tack, and tries to understand how the TTB functions as a rhetorical device. The gist of my argument is that it sanitizes the torture question of any real world difficulties, thereby making it appear as an act of governmental efficiency. I frame the paper in terms of Judith Butler’s work on administration detention policies, and in particular her appropriation of Foucault in that essay.

I’ve been accumulating a long file of writing notes and references since SPEP that do not appear in the current version of the paper; I suspect that I will end up with a second paper that goes into much greater detail on the efficiency arguments (as distinct from the rhetorical structure of the TTB scenario). But I am interested in what folks who have an interest in the topic think about the paper as it stands; part of my motivation in posting the current draft is to get myself kick-started into working on the next iteration.

Gordon