Category Archives: Reading Group

Idealization, Judicial Reasoning and Reasonableness: Replies on Chapter 5

Thanks very much to Lori to an extensive summary of Chapter 5 and probing comments. I hope that my replies continue to advance the discussion. I think there are some things I could clear up about the role of idealization … Continue reading

Posted in Politics, Reading Group | Tagged , , | 2 Comments

Sincerity, Individuation and Classical Liberal Public Reason: Comments on Chapter 4

Let me begin by thanking Blain for an excellent recap of Chapter 4 of the book, which is arguably the centerpiece chapter. He raises five important concerns, but I’m going to set two aside. First, Blain raises the question of … Continue reading

Posted in Reading Group | Tagged , | 9 Comments

Vallier Reading Group: Chapter 4

Summary of chapter 4 The goal of chapters 3 and 4 is to explain that the “Public Justification Principle” (PJP) does not entail the ‘principle of restraint.’ This involves showing that there is no necessary relation between the PJP and … Continue reading

Posted in Reading Group | Tagged , , , , , | 2 Comments

Integrity, Law and Congruence: Comments on Chapter 3

Thanks to Andrew Lister for an admirably concise and rich review of the third chapter of my book. The main aim of Chapter 3 is to lay down the strategy for vindicating the convergence view. I argue that respect for … Continue reading

Posted in Discussion, Politics, Reading Group | 5 Comments

Vallier Reading Group: Chapter 3

Summary Chapter 2 set out the argument linking public justifiability with restraint, advanced the integrity and fairness objections to restraint, and criticized the stability argument for restraint. Later chapters will attempt to uncouple public justifiability from restraint by arguing for … Continue reading

Posted in Posts, Reading Group | Tagged , , , , | Leave a comment

Publicity, Divisiveness and Restraint: Comments on Chapter 2

Let me begin by thanking Danny for commenting on my work. Danny and I overlapped in graduate school for three years, and he’s offered perceptive comments on my work ever since. So I’m especially grateful to him for his lengthy … Continue reading

Posted in Books, Discussion, Reading Group | 6 Comments